Reduced complexity of activity patterns in patients with Chronic Fatigue Syndrome: a case control study
© Burton et al; licensee BioMed Central Ltd. 2009
Received: 22 February 2009
Accepted: 02 June 2009
Published: 02 June 2009
Chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS) is an illness characterised by pervasive physical and mental fatigue without specific identified pathological changes. Many patients with CFS show reduced physical activity which, though quantifiable, has yielded little information to date. Nonlinear dynamic analysis of physiological data can be used to measure complexity in terms of dissimilarity within timescales and similarity across timescales. A reduction in these objective measures has been associated with disease and ageing. We aimed to test the hypothesis that activity patterns of patients with CFS would show reduced complexity compared to healthy controls.
We analysed continuous activity data over 12 days from 42 patients with CFS and 21 matched healthy controls. We estimated complexity in two ways, measuring dissimilarity within timescales by calculating entropy after a symbolic dynamic transformation of the data and similarity across timescales by calculating the fractal dimension using allometric aggregation.
CFS cases showed reduced complexity compared to controls, as evidenced by reduced dissimilarity within timescales (mean (SD) Renyi(3) entropy 4.05 (0.21) vs. 4.30 (0.09), t = -6.6, p < 0.001) and reduced similarity across timescales (fractal dimension 1.19 (0.04) vs. 1.14 (0.04), t = 4.2, p < 0.001). This reduction in complexity persisted after adjustment for total activity.
Patients with CFS show evidence of reduced complexity of activity patterns. Measures of complexity applied to activity have potential value as objective indicators for CFS.
Chronic Fatigue Syndrome (CFS) is a disorder characterised by profound physical and mental fatigue, with additional characteristic symptoms [1, 2]. While the exact cause remains unknown, both physiological and psychological processes have been implicated [3–5]. Although many of the symptoms of CFS are experienced within the body, increasing evidence points to altered central processing of sensations of fatigue and physical activity . Continuous measurement of physical activity (actigraphy) indicates that while some CFS patients show markedly reduced activity, others cannot be distinguished from healthy controls using conventional statistical techniques [2, 6]. The underlying physiological mechanisms which drive activity and rest are not fully understood, but recent work has identified a coherent structure to the distribution of long and short periods of activity, leading to the suggestion that the qualitative pattern of spontaneous activity over time may be centrally determined .
The analysis of complex patterns over time has been carried out for a number of physiological processes including heart rate variability , respiratory function  and gait  using techniques derived from the physics of nonlinear dynamic systems. Typically, this data shows two features: short-range (or within-scale) dissimilarity and long-range (or across-scale) similarity. (Here, scale refers to the choice of a particular viewing frame, typically with reference to space or time.) Together, these features are regarded as quantifiable characteristics of complexity which can be observed both in structure (complexity in space) and in behaviour (complexity in time). Work over the last 15 years has repeatedly demonstrated that health is a state of high complexity compared to disease and ageing . At first sight this appears paradoxical: the traditional view of healthy homeostasis is of relative constancy and order, which is then perturbed by the "disorder" of disease; however, as Goldberger and others have pointed out [11, 12], high complexity implies constant adaptability to an ever-changing environment, whereas low complexity implies inflexibility as is seen, for instance, in the unvarying stride length of patients with Parkinson's Disease . An example of the concept of within-scale dissimilarity and across-scale similarity is given below.
Two key features of complexity, dissimilarity within the same scale and similarity across scales ("self-similarity"), can be seen in the simple example of the structure of a tree and the way it branches. When viewed from the same distance, each branch of about the same size is different from every other in its branching pattern. However, when viewed from different distances, by "zooming" from far away – whereby only the trunk and main branches are seen – to close up – so that only a few outermost branches are visible – the branching pattern appears similar.
A measure of complexity in this case might thus include two components: how different each branch is compared to other branches of the same size, and how similar in pattern (but not size) branches of different size are.
Applying this approach to time series data, one would ask how different the activity is in each short period compared to other similar periods (dissimilarity within the same timescale), and how similar the stop and start patterns seen over 15 minutes are to those observed over 2 hours or over 12 hours (similarity across timescales).
Because conventional analysis of actigraphic data is unable to differentiate healthy controls from some, but not all, patients with CFS , and because of the suggestion that activity patterns represent the output of a complex central system , we sought to apply nonlinear dynamic analysis to actigraphy data from patients with CFS. To date, there has only been one published application of nonlinear dynamics to actigraphy data in CFS patients. That study found less similarity across timescales in cases than controls , in keeping with the hypothesis that illness is associated with loss of complexity, but did not include a measure of dissimilarity within timescales.
We aimed to test the hypothesis that objective measures of movement in both active and inactive patients with CFS would show reduced complexity – defined as dissimilarity within timescales and similarity across timescales – compared to healthy controls.
We used data from previous studies  of spontaneous movement in CFS in which data had been collected using a solid state activity meter (Actilog V3.0) worn continuously on the ankle. Data was recorded continuously over 12 days and saved as counts of movements for each five-minute period. No new data was collected for the purposes of this study. Participants had given informed consent for the recording and subsequent analysis of data through the ethical committee of the local institution.
We identified recordings from three categories of individuals defined in an earlier study  on the basis of clinical assessment and the overall pattern of the activity recordings: healthy controls, CFS patients with relatively normal activity (active CFS) and CFS patients with clearly reduced activity (inactive CFS). All cases met CDC criteria for CFS . Actigraph recorders were fitted to participants' ankles – giving them the choice for comfort – to avoid issues of dominance which would occur if the devices were applied to the wrist. Recordings were available from 21 healthy controls, so we selected the nearest match in age and sex from each of the two CFS groups. Although our earlier work  had suggested three categories of activity: pervasively inactive, relatively active and pervasively active, in accordance with our current clinical practice the relatively and pervasively active patients were grouped together.
Simple descriptive analysis of the data included mean, standard deviation and proportion of five-minute periods in which no movement was recorded. Measures of dissimilarity within timescales (entropy) and similarity across timescales (fractal dimension) were calculated for each individual participant, using methods described below, and results were compared between groups. Nonlinear dynamic measures were calculated using specifically written scripts in R, an open source language and environment for statistical computing and graphics , which was also used for the subsequent comparisons between cases and controls.
Dissimilarity within timescales
For the analysis of dissimilarity within timescales, we calculated informational entropy using symbolic dynamics . Entropy measures  can be used to describe the degree of variability in a data series and are derived from the notion that the more particular patterns recur in the data, the less information is required to describe the whole series. Thus, if one measures the frequency distribution of short subsequences within a larger data series, a low-entropy series will contain more recurring subsequences than one with high entropy.
We used the technique of symbolic dynamics to prepare the data for analysis. This approach converts a sequence of continuous values to discrete "words" representing subsequences in three steps. First, we condensed the individual time series to a limited number of values, in this case using terciles. Second, we represented each point as a symbol and third, we reconstructed the series as a sequence of overlapping qualitative "words" of a given number of symbols: for this study, we used a word length of 3 symbols. As an example, a sequence of values 1,8,7,10,1,3,5,12,7 would be converted to terciles (1,3,2,3,1,1,2,3,2), which were then translated to symbols (a, c, b, c, a, a, b, c, b). Finally, the sequence of symbols would be converted to overlapping three-letter words ("acb","cbc","bca",...).
Considering the words generated by this method, it can be understood that a completely random numerical series should generate all words with equal probability, whereas a simple periodic system (for instance 2,3,2,3,2,3,...) will generate only a small number of words – in this case two, "bcb" and "cbc".
For a random series of words comprising three symbols each with three possible values, the value of Shannon Entropy is 4.75.
To test the sensitivity of the algorithm to finite-size data series, we calculated Shannon and Renyi entropy for 50 series comprising 1200 uniformly distributed random numbers. The mean (SD) value for Shannon Entropy was 4.73 (0.006), close to the theoretical value of 4.75, and for Renyi Entropy 4.71 (0.018), with the parameter q = 3 (hereafter referred to as Renyi(3)).
After preliminary analysis of the data, we identified three necessary additional steps of data preparation. First, we removed all periods of prolonged rest, as the number of these differed between groups and we specifically wished to investigate activity. Rest was defined as three consecutive five-minute periods in which the mean activity count was below a given proportion of the mean activity count of the whole series. We carried out the analysis using thresholds of 16%, 25% and 33% of the mean series value. These were chosen arbitrarily after visual inspection of the data in order to provide a reasonably unbroken period of rest overnight while not obscuring brief periods of rest or reduced activity by day. Second, we differenced the data so that the series represented changes in activity rather than absolute activity levels; thus, the three symbols we used representing terciles of the individual differenced series can be interpreted as "reduce activity", "keep to around the same level of activity" and "increase activity". Cut points between the terciles were applied to each series individually rather than using pooled data. Third, we truncated all series to the length (after removal of resting periods) of the shortest.
Similarity across timescales
We measured similarity across timescales by allometric aggregation , which was developed by West  and colleagues to characterise scaling in biomedical data series and which can be used to derive the fractal dimension of the underlying process.
Our analysis of across-scale similarity was based on identifying correlations across multiple scales (so-called fractal correlations) in the data. Where those correlations are high, patterns are similar when viewed at different scales; conversely, they are dissimilar where correlations are low. The correlation strength increases with the local Hölder exponent h or, equivalently, with the fractal scaling exponent β = 2 h obtained from allometric aggregation . Alternatively, the fractal dimension D can be taken as a measure of the information required to describe a system across different scales. By Equation 3, D is negatively related to the fractal correlation, so that, as correlation increases (towards regularity), the fractal dimension decreases. Likewise, as correlation decreases (towards randomness), the dimension increases. In the context of a unidimensional time series, D = 1 corresponds to a completely regular process, whereas D = 1.5 represents an uncorrelated random process; healthy physiological processes operate somewhere in between these two extremes .
Comparison of measures of complexity between individuals
We used t-tests to compare the measures of dissimilarity within timescales (Shannon and Renyi entropy) in order to select the statistic that appeared to differentiate best between the controls and the two CFS groups. We then used analysis of covariance to identify the effect of group on the best-performing entropy statistic and on fractal dimension after adjusting for average activity. Separate comparisons were made for the active and inactive CFS cases with controls using dummy variables (control: 0 and case: 1). Finally we carried out a sensitivity analysis in which the two patients taking antidepressants or patients originally rated as pervasively active (2 active CFS cases and 8 controls) were removed from the analysis.
Patient characteristics and summary actigraphy results by participant group
Mean actigraphy score (SD)
Mean number of periods with zero movement (%)
Dissimilarity within timescales (entropy)
Comparison of complexity measures by group
3.4 p = 0.002
7.9 p < 0.001
2.1 p = 0.05
6.9 p < 0.001
2.5 p = 0.02
7.4 p < 0.001
1.8 p = 0.07
6.3 p < 0.001
Regression coefficients for diagnostic category with complexity measures as dependent variables
Comparison of Renyi(3) entropy obtained using different activity thresholds and word length
Similarity across timescales (fractal dimension)
When the patients on antidepressants were excluded there was no change in regression coefficients. When the 10 pervasively active patients were excluded the regression coefficient for active CFS compared to controls on Renyi(3) entropy, adjusting for mean activity, was unchanged although the p value was increased reflecting the reduced sample size (β = -0.07, p = 0.067).
Summary of main findings
This is the first study to report reduced complexity both within timescales and across timescales in the activity patterns of patients with CFS. Differences to healthy controls were seen in both active and inactive CFS cases. Regarding loss of dissimilarity within timescales, the differences in entropy measures between cases and controls remained statistically significant after adjusting for other characteristics of the data. Reduced similarity across timescales was accompanied by an increase in fractal dimension or, alternatively, by a reduced fractal scaling exponent, in keeping with previous studies of complexity loss through ageing and neurodegenerative disease . These findings support our hypothesis that CFS cases would show greater evidence of reduced complexity than controls and are in keeping with the model of disease as loss of complexity . They also suggest a new and quantifiable feature of CFS.
Strengths and weaknesses of the study
The data used for this study came from continuous recordings made during normal daily activities with few sources of bias in collection. Only objective data from the activity meters was used. All cases met current research diagnostic criteria for CFS, and the study included groups of patients with different severity as judged by total amount of activity. The methods of analysis have both been described elsewhere [15, 16] and shown to have discriminatory power in different contexts. Unlike some nonlinear analyses, they do not assume the presence of mathematical phenomena such as deterministic chaos , nor do they require very large sample sizes.
However, a number of arbitrary steps were introduced into the methods, and their role needs to be considered. The decision to eliminate rest periods for the analysis of dissimilarity within timescales was necessary because regularity statistics such as measures of entropy identify repeating patterns; if rest periods were not excluded, then sequences of zeros would become the dominant feature in the data. We considered only allowing recordings between certain times of day, but found that cases and controls differed in the timing and duration of apparent night-time and daytime rest periods and that only eliminating data with absolute zeros did not exclude minor night-time movements. Our method of allocating periods to activity or rest according to a threshold is in keeping with the approach taken by others .
Although Voss , who carried out a similar analysis with heartbeat series of 1200 points, used four- letter "words", we chose three letters, to represent increased activity, reduced activity and approximately unchanged activity. The decision to use differenced data reflecting changes in activity rather than absolute activity levels was made after inspecting the distribution of the undifferenced data and finding that cut points between terciles were relatively close together at low activity levels when undifferenced data was used.
Comparison with other studies
Most studies of dissimilarity within timescales in other conditions have used quantitative measures such as approximate entropy , or the related sample entropy , and their findings have generally supported the association between disease and loss of complexity. However, these methods depend on data which is distributed relatively uniformly around a mean value, a feature that the heavily skewed data used here did not possess. Techniques involving symbolic dynamics, which are less dependent on the fine-grained characteristics of the data series, have been applied successfully to address similar questions [15, 20]. Similarity across scales and long-term correlations in data have been addressed using a range of measures, typically detrended fluctuation analysis . However, like Ohashi et al. , we found that this did not differentiate cases from controls (data not shown). In their study, they measured similarity across timescales using the negative modulus maxima of the wavelet-transformed activity data which specifically relates to the cessation of activity. The results of our study were reported in terms of fractal correlations, which are negatively related to the fractal dimension: hence, the smaller correlations in CFS cases found by Ohashi et al.  are equivalent to the higher fractal dimension reported here; however, their study was smaller, and was unable to differentiate active CFS cases from controls.
Recently, the organisation of physical activity patterns, whereby periods of activity and rest are interwoven, has been shown to have a coherent structure across individuals and across timescales from 2 to 200 minutes [7, 22]. The activity patterns which we report are compatible with the complex physiological control system proposed to explain this finding.
Implications for future research and practice
Further study should investigate whether the reduced complexity we found is reversed in patients who recover, and how it relates to the changes in endocrine , immunological and cognitive function which are also seen in some patients with CFS. The notion that spontaneous activity patterns are centrally and involuntarily organised , and that the characteristics of this organisation are changed in CFS, may also provide useful foundations for explanatory models for this condition, in which rival explanations are frequently contested between patients and their doctors.
The spontaneous activity patterns of patients with CFS show significantly reduced complexity, compared to normal controls. This finding is similar to the reduced complexity seen in several other conditions and has potential as an objective marker for CFS which merits further investigation.
Chronic Fatigue Syndrome
- Fukuda K, Straus SE, Hickie I, Sharpe MC, Dobbins JG, Komaroff A: The chronic fatigue syndrome: a comprehensive approach to its definition and study. International Chronic Fatigue Syndrome Study Group. Ann Intern Med. 1994, 121: 953-959.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Prins JB, Meer van der JW, Bleijenberg G: Chronic fatigue syndrome. Lancet. 2006, 367: 346-355. 10.1016/S0140-6736(06)68073-2.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Cleare AJ: The HPA axis and the genesis of chronic fatigue syndrome. Trends Endocrinol Metab. 2004, 15: 55-59. 10.1016/j.tem.2003.12.002.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- de Lange FP, Kalkman JS, Bleijenberg G, Hagoort P, Werf van der SP, Meer van der JW, et al: Neural correlates of the chronic fatigue syndrome – an fMRI study. Brain. 2004, 127: 1948-1957. 10.1093/brain/awh225.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Deary V, Chalder T, Sharpe M: The cognitive behavioural model of medically unexplained symptoms: A theoretical and empirical review. Clinical Psychology Review. 2007, 27: 781-797. 10.1016/j.cpr.2007.07.002.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Werf van der SP, Prins JB, Vercoulen JH, Meer van der JW, Bleijenberg G: Identifying physical activity patterns in chronic fatigue syndrome using actigraphic assessment. J Psychosom Res. 2000, 49: 373-379. 10.1016/S0022-3999(00)00197-5.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Nakamura T, Kiyono K, Yoshiuchi K, Nakahara R, Struzik ZR, Yamamoto Y: Universal scaling law in human behavioral organization. Phys Rev Lett. 2007, 99: 138103-10.1103/PhysRevLett.99.138103.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Costa M, Goldberger AL, Peng CK: Multiscale entropy analysis of biological signals. Phys Rev E Stat Nonlin Soft Matter Phys. 2005, 71: 021906-View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Frey U: Predicting asthma control and exacerbations: chronic asthma as a complex dynamic model. Curr Opin Allergy Clin Immunol. 2007, 7: 223-230.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Hausdorff JM, Ashkenazy Y, Peng CK, Ivanov PC, Stanley HE, Goldberger AL: When human walking becomes random walking: fractal analysis and modeling of gait rhythm fluctuations. Physica A. 2001, 302: 138-147. 10.1016/S0378-4371(01)00460-5.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Goldberger AL, Amaral LAN, Hausdorff JM, Ivanov PC, Peng CK, Stanley HE: Fractal dynamics in physiology: Alterations with disease and aging. PNAS. 2002, 99: 2466-2472. 10.1073/pnas.012579499.PubMed CentralView ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- West BJ: Where medicine went wrong: rediscovering the path to complexity. 2006, Singapore: World Scientific PublishingGoogle Scholar
- Ohashi K, Bleijenberg G, van der Werf S, Prins J, Amaral LA, Natelson BH, et al: Decreased fractal correlation in diurnal physical activity in chronic fatigue syndrome. Methods Inf Med. 2004, 43: 26-29.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- R Development Core Team: R: A language and environment for statistical computing. 2006. 2005, Vienna, Austria, R Foundation for Statistical ComputingGoogle Scholar
- Kurths J, Voss A, Saparin P, Witt A, Kleiner HJ, Wessel N: Quantitative analysis of heart rate variability. Chaos. 1995, 5: 88-94. 10.1063/1.166090.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- West BJ, Griffin LA, Frederick HJ, Moon RE: The independently fractal nature of respiration and heart rate during exercise under normobaric and hyperbaric conditions. Respir Physiol Neurobiol. 2005, 145: 219-233. 10.1016/j.resp.2004.07.010.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- McSharry P: The danger of wishing for chaos. Nonlinear Dynamics Psychol Life Sci. 2005, 9: 375-397.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Voss A, Kurths J, Kleiner HJ, Witt A, Wessel N, Saparin P, et al: The application of methods of non-linear dynamics for the improved and predictive recognition of patients threatened by sudden cardiac death. Cardiovasc Res. 1996, 31: 419-433.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Pincus S: Approximate entropy (ApEn) as a complexity measure. Chaos. 1995, 5: 110-117. 10.1063/1.166092.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Peng CK, Yang AC, Goldberger AL: Statistical physics approach to categorize biologic signals: from heart rate dynamics to DNA sequences. Chaos. 2007, 17: 015115-10.1063/1.2716147.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Detrended Fluctuation Analysis. Physionet. 2001, [http://www.physionet.org/physiotools/dfa/]
- Nakamura T, Takumi T, Takano A, Aoyagi N, Yoshiuchi K, Struzik ZR, et al: Of mice and men – universality and breakdown of behavioral organization. PLoS ONE. 2008, 3: e2050-10.1371/journal.pone.0002050.PubMed CentralView ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar